Singing and Davening
Just returned from shul after extensive service. Much singing and extended lulav shaking. Is all this singing in Hol Hamoed appropriate. As one of my fellow congregants suggested it is time to put the Hol back into Hol Hamoed. The notion that community singing in itself is a marker of spiritual intensity seems at least questionable. Singing, like anything else, is susceptible to becoming routine and done just because it is done. Saving it for when it is really called for is a way of avoiding this problem. The spiritual potential of prayer properly conducted according to traditional nusach, with respect for the words, recited with dignity and conviction has come to be undervalued under the tide of Carlebachism that has overtaken us.

1 Comments:
dearest michael!
even though singing every day may turn it into a boring ritual. my personal opinion is that davoning without singing will turn dovening into a boring ritual! every chazan and shaliach ziubur in his own way and with his own tunes i speculate will turn every shacharit minha and aravit into a special experience... "העושה תפילתו קבע אין תפילתו תחננים" with much love -you'r darling doughter plushy
Post a Comment
<< Home